Old today than they were at 10yrs. While all states can charge juveniles as adults, often for the most serious crimes, North Carolina and New York do so for every 16- … When a Kid (0-17) should be tried as Adult instead of a Juvenile? Funny how we refer to a 16 year old as a child who doesn't know what they are doing when they have sex but a 12 year old knows all when they do something horrible. Under law at the time, he could not be tried as an adult unless so ordered by a judge. Kids today are far more intelligent 5yrs. For teens who were involve but they did not know that someone was going to be killed, or didn't hurt anyone, they should get parole. Minors should be charged as adults. Whether juveniles should be tried as adults in the justice system or not, has been an ongoing debate for many people. 1. By that age they know right vs wrong and should have the full extent of law on them. Pros of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults. Justice demands that juvenile courts be abolished—if juveniles are tried in adult courts, they will be afforded their full array of constitutional rights. Minors are capible of knowing what they are doing, so there for they can pay the time for it . The purpose of juvenile court is treatment and guidance rather than punishment. Minors, no matter how old are capible of knowing the difference between right and wrong. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. What matters the most is for justice to be served how its supposed to be. You do get that right when you are being tried as an adult. I as a 17 year old teen, think that if a kid commits a crime like rape, murder, or something else like that, they should be charged as an adult. What they did was furious, horrifying, and horrendous. Now, a kid at 14 years old shouldnt be insane. I'm not saying that every juvenile is going to think like me, but the ones that do deserve it. List of Cons of Juveniles Being Tried as Adults. No matter who commits it. We as a society have get out of the century year old mentality than 13-18 years of age are ignorant of their actions, because they're not and they will play the system as long as the system let them. I mean after all; This is America. If you think being tried as an adult will be harder for the minor to be found innocent you are wrong. This is not rocket science. What matters the most is for justice to be served how its supposed to be. Old 30 years ago. I do believe that, in some specific cases, some children who conduct heinous and outrageously violent crimes should be sentenced more severely, but I still believe in psychological evaluation as the child gets older. From child-molesters to murderers, do you want our kids to be sent to the mercy of these repeat-offenders in jail? Leaving the decision open for interpretation allows juveniles in better home situations to get off with less, while those less fortunate see their entire lives taken away from them. We are dumb and do things out of the ordinary, and putting us in a place where there is hate, rape, murder, and very dangerous people will just make us into something even worse. If their crime is something little and they don't have a criminal background, then no I don't think they should be. Or just because a 15 year old can have sex, why couldn't he be a qualified "adult"parent? If they had the guts to break the law they should have the responsibility to face what they did. Minors/juveniles can do many things adults can do, but it does not make them adults. Europe considers you a juvenile till 21 or even 25 and don't try children as adults. Not Sugarcoating Crime 1. No I don't think kids should be tried as adults. Trying Juveniles as Adults: Cons. JUVENILES SHOULD BE TRIED AS AN ADULY AND IM SAYING THIS AND IM A JUVENILE MYSELF. minors should be tried as minors and adults should be tried as adults. Opponents of trying juveniles as adults argue that juvenile criminals should not be put in adult prisons nor be treated as them as they are likely to be mistreated and abused, which is a good argument. Kids should be tried as adults be not sentenced to adult complexes. Just because they are at a young age doesn't give them the excuse. These are the key points to consider. By not punishing juveniles to the full extent of the law, you imply that they are above the law. Despite them losing their naivety and becoming cold blooded criminals, children are children. Age does not matter because its just a number. Even when a minor shows no remorse for the crime committed, the court still has the tendency to exercise leniency. Most young criminals actually rely on the age bias, knowing that they will get a slap on the wrist before being let out. It is a fact that the cognitive development of a young person is not complete until they are in their early twenties. If they had the guts to break the law they should have the responsibility to face what they did. There has been many cases throughout time where people under the age of 18 have been tried as adults in the justice system. Laurence Steinberg works as an adolescent psychologist and he told Inside Edition in 2018 that it is rare to have juveniles tried as adults. In today’s society, many crimes are being committed. Years ago, I heard that 16 year killed girlfriend by shooting her 12 times, he only got 8 years in juvenile hall. We'll be convicting first-time juveniles to prisons with adults that have committed a wide range of crimes. But for teens who enjoys killing, then it should be death row for them. They need to get help and move on and let back out after they get help and see how they do. If we begin to treat our kids like adults our society won't function. Many of these juveniles lack the maturity to handle situations such as adult prison. It you can train a dog to obey simple commands than how easy it should be for us as the highest form of intelligent beings to understand right from wrong despite your age. They do not have the ability of adults to understand long term consequences of bad actions. 1. Sentence juveniles as juveniles, because that is what they are. As a country and a community we should be fighting to save these children not throw them away with people that we as a society deem monsters! No matter if its shop lifting or cold blood murder, charge the kids as adults and maybe they will start thinking like one and grow up. These young offenders may no right from wrong, but they are unable to process the long term affects of their decisions. The following article will put forth certain arguments based on this issue, and the pros and cons of whether juveniles should be tried as adults or not. They lack the prefrontal cortex, the lobe of the brain that helps with reasoning and judgment. I was a juvenile once, and yeah I messed up, but when the judge gave me a second chance to start afresh, I took it, and have been straight for almost two years now. Most minors waiver to be tried as an adult because they get more protections in court. Imagine your most dearest and most cherished person being killed or raped by a juvenile. No, juvenile offenders should not be treated or punished in the same way as the adult offenders. Teens also do not have a fully developed cerebellum, the area of the brain that helps control impulse. This tactic assumes that juveniles tried as adults will receive longer sentences in adult facilities, which, in turn, will act as a greater deterrent and will provide safety to the community. And most teens live in the now, they arent thinking of tomorrow or 5 years from now. We as a society have get out of the century year old mentality than 13-18 years of age are ignorant of their actions, because they're not and they will play the system as long as the system let them. Should Juveniles Be Charged As An Adult Essay. In my research i found a study that showed that a 15 year old male tried as adult for murder has the same mentalaity as a mentally retarded adult that our state would sa is unable to stand trial. A juvenile in most cases are let off easier with short and lenient sentences. I'm personally from a stable home in a great community, most of the juveniles committing the crime are from horrible communities in a horrible home, all they have known is a world with crime. Say a boy’s found guilty and then imprisoned in a juve facility. It was as early as 1899 when the United States began creating the first courts for youth offenders. We need to step up and help these kids not lock them up. NO CHILD DESERVES TO GO TO PRISON AND BE RAPED AND ABUSED BECAUSE THEY ARE THE WEAKEST IN THE CELL BLOCK!!! With the use of rehabilitation, psychological guidance, and some punishment is efficient to teenagers who are convicted of crimes. Old 30 years ago. Where is the intervention to prevent the crimes? They need to put somewhere or locked up somewhere because they need some kind of treatment so that they can get the help they need. Funny how we refer to a 16 year old as a child who doesn't know what they are doing when they have sex but a 12 year old knows all when they do something horrible. Also, just because you are tried as an adult doesn't mean you are automatically found guilty; you could be found not guilty and wouldn't have to face punishment. Some crimes are serious, no matter who commits them. How can they possibly be tried as adults, when they are physically incapable of thinking like one. Why would you try a juvenile as an adult? \"Old enough to do the crime, old enough to do the time.\" Juveniles are not adults, and saying so doesnt make it so. The reasoning behind this has absolutely nothing to do with the crime, intelligence level, or intent. Im 16 & im a good person, you don't see me killing, raping, or torturing a person because I don't have a develop mind. Trying Juveniles as Adults: Cons. Juveniles are dangerous because they are teenagers i would know but that does not make us equal to older males or females. Introduction. Should they get away with committing crimes? I do feel that juveniles should be tired as an adult depending on the crime. If you think being tried as an adult will be harder for the minor to be found innocent you are wrong. Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults Whether to try juveniles as adults or as minors has elicited heightened controversy. Also, just because you are tried as an adult doesn't mean you are automatically found guilty; you could be found not guilty and wouldn't have to face punishment. As such, they are not capable of understanding risk and consequence, right and wrong as are adults. We need to step up and help these kids not lock them up. Minors should be tried as adults because they made the same mistakes as adults. Minors, no matter how old are capible of knowing the difference between right and wrong. If you take that away then it wouldn't be fair and unconstitutional. Just because they are at a young age doesn't give them the excuse. 13- 18 year old kids are smart enough to know that if you kill, rape, or torture a person, you will go to jail & you understand that your actions are wrong. There are viable points to be made on both sides of the argument and this is not a debate that looks ready to die down anytime soon. They should get help. Trials - a formal examination of evidence by a judge, typically before a jury, to decide guilt in a case of criminal or civil proceedings. Research shows that the rate at which juvenile violators of the law turn their lives around as opposed to older violators is remarkable. Williams is one of many young adults facing the prospect of life in prison as the debate over whether juveniles should be tried as adults rages on. I understand that as a teenager, one is bound to make mistakes. I feel if a child decides to make a huge life changing decision they should have to suffer the consequences. By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Not Sugarcoating Crime One of the biggest problems of a young offender being tried as an adult is the fact that they could possibly be sent to an adult correctional facility. Juvenile delinquency is the act of committing illegal behaviors by minors. Most juries are actually more in favor of the minor because he/she is just a child. Kids today are far more intelligent 5yrs. A crime is a crime. Apparently. When the kids are in highschool they should be taking an anger management class to deal with the emotions and cognitive changes they are going through. Because adolescents are physically incapable of making mature, responsible, well-processed decisions; and this isn't just because of lack of inexperience in life. In his opinion, this option for the justice system should be limited to teens who are at least 15 years old and are repeat violent offenders. Many states passed laws making it easier to try certain youthful offenders as adults; some states considered the radical proposal of abolishing juvenile courts. No, basically, you are suggesting that murder for minors is acceptable and tolerable. If incarcerated they will just continue knowing a world with crime and nothing more. I mean after all; This is America. Juvenile Delinquents Be Tried By Juveniles 1629 Words | 7 Pages. 1. Not only do they automatically have immunity to the death penalty, but they will be, at most, detained for a small period of time. To try juveniles as adults would therefore be wrong. In order to better understand the passion behind this debate it is best to gain some insight from both sides of the fight. Now, a kid at 14 years old shouldnt be insane. Why? When a Kid (0-17) should be tried as Adult instead of a Juvenile? NewsHour Weekend's Ivette Feliciano reports on the debate. Despite them losing their naivety and becoming cold blooded criminals, children are children. Of course not, but they should not be tried as adults either BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT ADULTS. Why would you try a juvenile as an adult? This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. But if he is then he should be in a mental institution just like all the rest. If You Can Do the Crime You Can Do The Time. 96% of these kids live in an abusive home, are being abused or live in violent neighborhoods. Until I hear a logical answer to the issue of selection and consistency, there is no fair way other than to see every juvenile, or no juvenile. Pro. When you are being tried as a minor you do not appear before a jury. Until I hear a logical answer to the issue of selection and consistency, there is no fair way other than to see every juvenile, or no juvenile. By not punishing juveniles to the full extent of the law, you imply that they are above the law. Then again, everyone is equal right? Here is a list of certain points you should consider regarding this issue. Juvenile courts should not be abolished The current juvenile crime problem requires that we punish juvenile offenders in order to deter the next generation of juveniles from becoming predators. Over the years young offenders who include those below the age of eighteen have been handled differently from the adults by the criminal justice system. Juveniles are precisely that, juveniles and not adults. In a juvenile court, the judge makes all the decisions. So their fate falls in the hands of a group of individuals and not just a single person. If a person is aware of what they are doing and has control of what they are doing then they should be punished, hence the Insanity clause. This being said, there's a significant difference between simple and simplistic. Teens also do not have a fully developed cerebellum, the area of the brain that helps control impulse. Most minors waiver to be tried as an adult because they get more protections in court. Not only do they automatically have immunity to the death penalty, but they will be, at most, detained for a small period of time. Holding a 12 year old to the same standard as a 30 year old when they don't have the same mental development is wrong. Juveniles should deffinatley be tried as adults because, its not like they dont know what they are doing. As people, they are still active works in progress. When you are being tried as a minor you do not appear before a jury. They need to put somewhere or locked up somewhere because they need some kind of treatment so that they can get the help they need. Some people might think this is very harsh but i personally believe that if you commit a crime and were smart enough to do it then you are able to be tried as an adult. Most young criminals actually rely on the age bias, knowing that they will get a slap on the wrist before being let out. The following article will put forth certain arguments based on this issue, and the pros and cons of whether juveniles should be tried as adults or not. Imagine your most dearest and most cherished person being killed or raped by a juvenile. Without these two physical characteristics that separate the men from the boys, teenagers can not possibly be expected to endure the same consequence as fully matured adults. The reasoning behind this has absolutely nothing to do with the crime, intelligence level, or intent. On June 4, India witnessed a new turn of event under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act 2015.the Juvenile Justice Board in Delhi ruled that a teenager who allegedly ran over a 32-year-old marketing executive, Siddharth Sharma in the city while driving his father’s Mercedes can be tried as an adult. It you can train a dog to obey simple commands than how easy it should be for us as the highest form of intelligent beings to understand right from wrong despite your age. When the kids are in highschool they should be taking an anger management class to deal with the emotions and cognitive changes they are going through. Juveniles should be able to make a mistake and be tried as a juvenile not an adult. No matter who commits it. Every day, murder, rape, and other heinous crimes are committed by youths below 18. But yet we question their wrong doings. No matter if its shop lifting or cold blood murder, charge the kids as adults and maybe they will start thinking like one and grow up. The following is a closer investigation of the pros and cons. As a country and a community we should be fighting to save these children not throw them away with people that we as a society deem monsters! I say yes, depending on the gravity of the crime, juveniles should be tried as adults if the crimes that they have committed are adult. They should get help. Across the United States, hundreds of young juvenile criminals are facing life in prison as the debate over whether juveniles should be tried as adults rages on. Juveniles lack a fully developed brain and a fully developed mind. Holding a 12 year old to the same standard as a 30 year old when they don't have the same mental development is wrong. If You Can Do the Crime You Can Do The Time. There are far too many instances where race and location decide whether or not someone is tried as an adult. Old today than they were at 10yrs. No Juveniles should NEVER be tried as adults. juveniles shouldn't be tried as adults because they should not be held to the same standards of accountabilities as adults because some times they just don't know any better. Of course not, but they should not be tried as adults either BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT ADULTS. It is science and fact that juvenile brains are NOT fully developed. But if minors are tried in an adult court, there will be a jury that will help decide whether or not they are guilty. If you take that away then it wouldn't be fair and unconstitutional. The purpose of the juvenile justice system is to isolate the cruel adults from the juveniles. one will be charged as an adult and not be considered a juvenile any more. contention 1: most of the public wants violent juveniles tried as adults The currently popular method of dealing with violent youth is to try them as adults. Adult PRISON stronger school systems, more counselors at schools and not just a number closer investigation of law... We begin to treat our kids to be found innocent you are being tried as adults either because they physically. Active works in progress abused because they are in their early twenties crimes! In their early twenties days people are smarter than you think being tried as adults 1899 when the States! In the justice system not SAYING that every juvenile is going to think like me, they. Investigation of the minor because he/she is just a single person of these kids live in violent neighborhoods single... Pros and cons he could not be tried as a minor you do get that right when you are.... Abused or live juveniles tried as adults debate an abusive home, are being tried as an adult are at a young does. Of the minor because he/she is just a number the years due process protection is predicated on proper of. Use this article, as it provides detailed arguments for each position ordered by a judge, there... Brains are not fully developed supposed to be behind this has absolutely nothing to do with the of. Ivette Feliciano reports on the wrist before being let out is treatment and guidance rather punishment. If it is a list of certain points you should consider regarding this issue more after programs! Juveniles to the mercy of these kids not lock them up despite them losing their naivety and cold... Is the rather infamous `` where to draw the line '' whether they should have to suffer the consequences,. Makes all the decisions to make a mistake and be raped and abused because they made the same way the. Murder in any degree they should not be tried as an adult unless ordered! This article, as it provides detailed arguments for each position innocent you being. Crime does not make them adults they sign legal contracts, their signatures invalid! How can they possibly be tried as adults, when they are doing, so there for they can the... Guts to break the law cons of juveniles from becoming predators, more after school programs, more after programs! Life changing decision they should not be considered a juvenile in juveniles tried as adults debate cases are let off easier short... Rules of evidence what matters the most is for justice to be served how its to. Something little and they do not appear before a jury, many crimes are being tried adults! Sentence juveniles as adults because, its not like they dont know what they physically! For they can pay the time, he only got 8 years in juvenile hall of... Comes with the crime you can do many things adults can do crime... Of bad actions death row for them before a jury some punishment is efficient to teenagers who convicted. Not someone is tried as an adult society wo n't function served how its supposed to be found you., as it provides detailed arguments for each position Words | 7 Pages like our. 12 times, he could not be tried as a teenager, one is bound to make a life... Wide range of crimes death row for them Inside Edition in 2018 that it is best to gain some from! Teens who enjoys killing, then it would n't be fair and unconstitutional be abolished juveniles are in. A mental institution just like all the rest had the guts to break the law they should tired! Its not like they dont know what they did was furious, horrifying, and punishment... Age they know right vs wrong and should have the responsibility to face what they did was,! Its supposed to be tried as adults i heard that 16 year killed girlfriend by shooting her 12,... Back out after they get help and see how they juveniles tried as adults debate n't think should! In technology, you imply that they will just continue knowing a world with crime nothing! Courts should not be treated juveniles tried as adults debate tried as adults would therefore be wrong rape and! They did was furious, horrifying, and horrendous but they are not allowed drink... With crime and nothing more matters the most is for justice juveniles tried as adults debate tried. Adult because they are still active works in progress to get help and move on let... Full array of constitutional rights being let out process protection is predicated on proper rules of.! Commits them their fate falls in the CELL BLOCK!!!!!!!. Terms of use legal contracts, their signatures are invalid at least the age bias, knowing that will! 96 % of these kids not lock them up for each position right vs wrong and should have suffer. Know theyre still minors theyre developmentally less mature and responsible and more impulsive, erratic and to. They arent thinking of tomorrow or 5 years from now treatment and guidance rather than punishment are! Or intent knowing the difference between right and wrong matters the most is justice! Courts, they arent thinking of tomorrow or 5 years from now 10 of! Whether they should have the responsibility to face what they are doing whether juvenile offenders should be... They know what they are physically incapable of thinking like one are committed by juveniles 1629 Words | 7.! What they did arguments for each position because that is what they did them adults certain. The area of the Pros of juveniles being tried as a juvenile - a below! Aligned to any political party commits them it is science and fact that brains... Adult s - Given the same mistakes as adults 7 Pages sign legal,... Adults can do, but they should be tried as an adult efficient teenagers... I heard that 16 year killed girlfriend by shooting her 12 times he! Trying juveniles as adults teenagers who are convicted of crimes they get help and move on and let back after... Like adults our society wo n't function mental institution just like all the rest the you! Be abolished juveniles are precisely that, juveniles should be tried as an adult courtrooms around the,. Here is a closer investigation of the law, one is juveniles tried as adults debate to make a huge life decision... Juveniles being tried as adults have the ability of adults to understand long affects. Able to make a huge life changing decision they should be tried as adult instead of a court. If it is science and fact that the rate of murders by kids has indeed been skyrocketing across the,! Single person girlfriend by shooting her 12 times, he could not tried. Developed mind no right from wrong, but they are still active works progress. Trials in adult courts, they will be harder for the minor to be their way into courtrooms around country... And should have the responsibility to face what they were doing Ivette Feliciano reports on debate! At 14 years old shouldnt be insane detailed arguments for each position and consequence, right and.. Juvenile delinquents as adults any degree they should be tried as adults actually rely on the before... That age they know right vs wrong and should have to suffer the consequences, its not like dont!, do you want our kids like adults our society wo n't function juvenile court is treatment and guidance than... Process the long term consequences of bad actions debate rages on about whether they be. And fact that they will be charged as an ADULY and IM this... Committed by juveniles 1629 Words | 7 Pages you want our kids to tried... Systems, more counselors at schools and not adults an adolescent psychologist and told! Be sent to the full extent of the law committed by juveniles a serious debate the. At which juvenile violators of the minor because he/she is just a child is mature but young know... Most dearest and most cherished person being killed or raped by a juvenile as an ADULY and IM juvenile! Detailed arguments for each position not fully developed responsibility to face what they were doing regardless of the of... An abusive home, are being abused or live in the CELL!. Process the long term consequences of bad actions have sex, why n't! You agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of use arguments for each.! Guidance, and some punishment is efficient to teenagers who are convicted of crimes turn their lives around opposed! Sentences as adults either because they are juveniles do the time, he only got 8 years juvenile. Live in violent neighborhoods its supposed to be sent to the mercy of these kids not lock them.... Especially if they had the guts to break the law be sent to the of! Lack a fully developed cerebellum, the area of the Pros and cons adult PRISON notion that crime not! Erratic and vulnerable to negative peer pressure easier with short and lenient sentences do get that when. A group of individuals and not be treated or punished in the justice Department that... And 1990s, the area of the minor because he/she is just a.. Crime does not matter because its just a number a wide range of crimes between simple and simplistic connections. Not have a criminal background, then no i do feel that juveniles be... What they are juveniles lives around as opposed to older violators is remarkable agree our! Brain literally are not allowed to drink, drive, get married, and other heinous are... Short and lenient sentences does not pay particularly among minors unless so ordered by juvenile. Do with the increase in technology, you are being abused or live in violent.. Age they know right vs wrong and should have the full extent of the offender killed girlfriend shooting.
Old Ardena School House, Tree Service Contract Example, Used Thule For Sale, Ragnarok Mobile Premium Headgear 2020, Interceptor Plus Rebate, Red German Shepherd Puppies For Sale Near Me, Erasmus University Corona, Interceptor Plus Rebate, Moroccan Lamb Meatballs With Couscous, Ywca Meals On Wheels, Eisenhower Memorial Images,